Why I Stopped Telling People to "Picture Everyone in Their Underwear": The Real Truth About Conquering Public Speaking Fear

Related Articles:

• Managing Difficult Conversations
• Stress Management Training

Seventeen years ago, I was standing in front of 200 mining executives in Perth, sweating through my shirt despite the air conditioning running at arctic levels, when I realised that everything I'd been taught about public speaking was complete rubbish.

The trembling hands? The racing heart? The voice that sounded like I'd been sucking helium? None of the textbook advice was working. Not the deep breathing. Not the positive self-talk. And definitely not picturing my audience naked (seriously, who came up with that one?).

That moment changed everything about how I approach public speaking training today.

The Problem with Traditional Public Speaking Advice

Here's what most trainers won't tell you: 89% of public speaking anxiety stems from preparation issues, not performance nerves. Yet we spend all our time treating the symptoms instead of the disease.

I've watched countless professionals torture themselves with mantras and meditation apps when what they really needed was a solid structure and realistic expectations. The fear isn't irrational - it's completely logical when you're unprepared.

Take my client Sarah from Adelaide last month. Brilliant engineer, terrible presenter. She'd been to three different public speaking courses that taught her breathing techniques and positive visualisation. Still terrified.

Why? Because nobody had bothered to teach her how to organise her content properly.

What Actually Works (And What Doesn't)

The stuff that works:

• Having three key points maximum
• Starting with data your audience already agrees with
• Ending before people expect you to
• Practicing your opening line until it's automatic
• Accepting that some nervousness is actually helpful

The stuff that's useless:

• Imagining your audience in underwear (creepy and distracting)
• "Just be yourself" (terrible advice if yourself is terrified)
• Memorising your entire speech word-for-word
• Focusing on eliminating all nervousness

The dirty secret of the speaking industry? Most trainers have never had to present quarterly results to a hostile board. They've never had to explain to 50 tradies why safety protocols are changing. They've never stood in front of angry customers demanding refunds.

Real-world presenting is different from TED talks and Toastmasters.

The Australian Approach: Keep It Simple, Keep It Real

Australians have an advantage in public speaking that most don't recognise. We're naturally sceptical of over-polished presentations. We prefer straight talk to flowery rhetoric.

This works in our favour. But it also means we often under-prepare because we think "winging it" is authentically Australian.

Wrong.

The best Australian presenters I know - and I'm thinking specifically of leaders at companies like Atlassian and Canva - combine natural conversational style with meticulous preparation. They sound casual. They've actually rehearsed extensively.

My Five-Step Process (That Actually Works in Brisbane Boardrooms)

1. Start with your ending. Know exactly how you're finishing before you worry about your opening.
2. Build three pillars. Your main content should rest on exactly three key points. Not four. Not two. Three.
3. Test your opening on someone. Your partner, your teenager, your dog. Someone who'll tell you if it's boring.
4. Time everything. If you think your presentation is 20 minutes, it's actually 35. Plan accordingly.
5. Have a backup plan. Technology fails. Rooms are too small. Audiences are distracted. Professional presenters adapt.

I learned this the hard way during a disaster in Melbourne's CBD three years ago. The projector died, half the audience was stuck in traffic, and the CEO was running 40 minutes late.

My client still needed to deliver quarterly updates to 30 department heads. We threw out the slides, grabbed a whiteboard, and had the most engaging session they'd had all year.

Preparation saved us. Not positive thinking.

The Uncomfortable Truth About "Natural" Speakers

Here's something that might surprise you: most "natural" public speakers are actually highly anxious people who've learned to channel their nervousness into energy.

I know presenters who've been speaking professionally for decades who still get nervous before important presentations. The difference? They've learned to use that adrenaline instead of fighting it.

The myth of the naturally confident speaker is damaging because it makes normal people feel like failures. You're not supposed to feel completely calm before presenting to your industry's top brass. You're supposed to care enough to be nervous.

What I Wish Someone Had Told Me 20 Years Ago

Stop trying to eliminate fear. Start trying to harness it.

Your nervousness means you care about the outcome. That's good. Your sweaty palms mean your body is preparing for something important. Also good.

The goal isn't to feel like you're chatting with friends over coffee. The goal is to communicate your message clearly despite feeling nervous.

Big difference.

I've seen too many talented professionals avoid promotions because they're terrified of presenting. I've watched brilliant ideas die in committee rooms because their creators couldn't articulate them confidently.

This isn't just about public speaking. It's about career advancement, business growth, and personal development.

The Reality Check: Most Presentations Are Boring

Before you stress too much about being perfect, remember this: most business presentations are terrible. Your audience's expectations are probably lower than you think.

Show up prepared, speak clearly, and finish on time? You're already in the top 30% of corporate presenters.

Have three clear points supported by relevant data? Top 15%.

End with a specific call to action? Top 5%.

The bar isn't as high as you think it is. But it's also not as low as some people assume.

What I Tell My Clients in Sydney (And Everywhere Else)

Perfect presentations don't exist. Effective presentations do.

Your job isn't to be the next Steve Jobs. Your job is to communicate your message clearly enough that your audience can act on it.

Sometimes that means admitting you don't know something. Sometimes it means going off-script when someone asks an unexpected question. Sometimes it means laughing when technology fails.

The best presenters I work with treat public speaking like any other professional skill. They practice regularly, seek feedback, and continuously improve.

They don't wait until they feel confident. They start speaking while they're still nervous and build confidence through repetition.

---

Our Favourite Resources:

• Dealing with Difficult Behaviours Training

The fear never completely goes away. But the skills get stronger. And eventually, the skills matter more than the fear.

That's something worth speaking up about.